Operation Grapple X - 140 times the size of the Hiroshima bomb

Michelle Harding • Nov 08, 2021

Operation Grapple X, 8 November 1957, Christmas Island.

 

 In 1955 Sir Anthony Eden approached New Zealand’s Prime Minister with a request to use the Kermadec Islands as a testing site on the principle of the Commonwealth defence effort.


He hoped that “in the interest of our common defence effort and the importance of the deterrent for Commonwealth Strategy, you will find it possible to agree”. 


We now know that the New Zealand government did not agree and Operation Grapple was held at Malden and Christmas Islands.


Today at 17.47 GMT marks the sixty-fourth anniversary of Round ‘C’ in the nine-part Grapple X series over Christmas Island and Malden Island.

 

It was an air drop by a Squadron RAF Valiant XD824 at 2250m which followed the underperforming Short Granite and Purple Granite.

 

A two staged design gave a yield of 1.8 MT, 140 times the size of the Hiroshima bomb.


The anticipated yield was underestimated by a whopping 80%, the shock wave damage was thus greater than expected and demolished buildings, equipment and infrastructure.


All bombs were dropped from the air either by RAF Valiant or tethered to barrage balloons and so produced high fallout.


Grapple thermonuclear designs were never put into service but were used to announce Britain’s thermonuclear status to the world which duly led to the UK-US Mutual Defense Agreement (1958) and ensured that the USA and the UK would once again work in tandem amidst fears of an imminent Test ban.


I have read many descriptions of Christmas Island...


Air Vice Marshal Wilfred Oulton CB CBE DSO DFC describes Christmas Island in his book, "Christmas Cracker", as the “largest coral island in the world”. 


Group Captain Kenneth Hubbard (1985) describes an idyllic scene in his book, "Dropping Britain's First H-bomb: Story of Operation Grapple 1957", “The sun was still at a low angle producing a glittering effect on the clear blue Pacific”, which very quickly evolves into, “The clear air over an uninhabited island would be shattered by man’s scientific and technological ability” (page 93).


As Round C provides, “A sight of such majesty and grotesque beauty that …....... defies adequate description”; “The pride of AWRE culmination, the sense of occasion, Awe-inspiring" (Page 96).


Hubbard recalls the tangible sense of excitement and the euphoria of success.


Servicemen are described as guinea pigs as they moved around the island consuming fruits and fish which were swimming in the same contaminated lagoon as the men themselves and ingesting fallout dust (Baron 2008).


Ken McGinley, in his book, "No Risk Involved", describes killing injured birds, some still blindly flying around at the end of his duty.


I often wonder what was the average experience and the sensations felt by the Serviceman?


We can get a flavour of that in "Just Testing" by Derek Robinson (1985), “It was rather frightening when they set the bomb off, like, you know I’d never seen an explosion before, or heard one. And it was rather frightening. We’d got no protective clothing as such. Just shorts, and short-sleeved shirts, that’s all we had, and a pair of sunglasses"; “It took us completely by surprise because we didn’t expect this”. “Even then it wasn’t frightening to me, we were only boys, we were adventurous, I mean why should we be frightened at 21 and 22?”


“Twas absolutely tremendous. We had one of the best twelve months I’ve ever had as a boy...”


However, all the reading shows a total dichotomy of experience; we are human and react in different ways and that is perfectly alright. Different people have different impressions and recall of what happened that day and other test days. Your recall is valid, even if it is totally different to that of the man standing on the deck next to you, or decontaminating an aircraft.


As oral historian for the BNTVA, I hear many different accounts from many people including veterans and descendants; the man who has so much pride in his part in the tests, the family who is so proud of their relative or the men who cried and shouted in fear. All these experiences are valid and I do not judge people in any way for recounting their memories and experiences – it is an absolute privilege and honour for me to record your “stories”. I would be most happy to hear your account and different memories provide a fuller picture of your personal memory of the British Atomic Testing. If you would like to do this, please don’t hesitate to contact me either on social media or by email (m.harding@bntva.com).


It is also coming up to Remembrance Day, I’ll be honest I find this time of year hard, anniversaries are and it has been just a year since I lost both my parents. If you need someone to chat with, the BNTVA phone is on for Remembrance Day, please feel free to telephone if you need someone to chat with then or on any day. The BNTVA is here for you now and in the future whether you are a veteran, partner or descendant.

 

 

 

 

 

 

24 Jun, 2023
The National Service of Remembrance, held at The Cenotaph in Whitehall on Remembrance Sunday, provides the nation with a physical reminder of all those who have served and sacrificed, with British and Commonwealth soldiers, sailors, airmen and women represented, together with members of the emergency services and civilians, ensuring that no-one is forgotten.
23 Jun, 2023
Return to Tradition...
21 Jun, 2023
We have an update on the current situation regarding the provision of Coffin Drapes and Standard Bearers for the funerals of BNTVA veterans.
21 Jun, 2023
NAVAD will be celebrated at the National Memorial Arboretum at Alrewas, Staffordshire this year on Sunday 1st October 2023.
10 Jun, 2023
To all BNTVA Members Due to the issues being faced by the BNTVA, we are currently unable to produce or circulate editions of Campaign magazine. To assist with the very real need to get information out to its membership the BNTVA Trustees asked exposure magazine if they would accept an editorial section from the BNTVA. Because exposure is an editorial-based publication our team had to confirm with the constituent organisations that they sanctioned the measure. We are pleased to say that they have approved this inclusion as a benefit to our nuclear community. Within the BNTVA Editorial section, you will find announcements and information on the activities of the BNTVA. If you are not a member of the BNTVA but would like to become a supporter after reading this section please contact Shelly Grigg: s.grigg@bntva.com BNTVA Membership PO Box 8244 Castle Donington DE74 2BY
24 Mar, 2023
The Trustees have decided to set the Direct Debit amount to £0 for this year and will not process any cheques, they will be destroyed. Any payments already processed will be offered refunds. This is in recognition of the current financial hardship being suffered by many of our members and the poor service given by the BNTVA last year. Due to the restrictions on litigation, we remain unable to comment on certain matters and this will continue for at least the next six weeks after which we should be in a position to disclose everything to our members. We can certainly state that malicious gossip and speculation that the charity is suspended and being investigated by the Charity Commission is utter tripe. The only investigations being conducted at this moment are into former employees and members of the BNTVA. We have recently secured a significant court ruling in relation to the BNTVA archival material and as soon as the case is finalised we will also report on the matter. There have also been deliberate lies circulated about the archives and artefacts of the BNTVA. We can state that we are working to ensure no member of the Nuclear Community nor Researcher or Journalist working to the benefit of our community will ever have to pay to access the archives and artefacts of the BNTVA and that they will be protected in the future from the political upheavals that have been the hallmark of the BNTVA since its inception.
by Wesley Perriman 05 Feb, 2023
The BNTVA have received numerous enquiries regarding the Chef Executive Officer.
by Wesley Perriman 23 Jan, 2023
We are mindful that there is a lot of speculation and uncertainty as to what is happening with the BNTVA. Firstly we want to assure you that the organisation is still active and will be around for many years to come providing key services to our beneficiaries and associate membership.
by Ceri McDade 09 Nov, 2022
Open invitation from the Office of Veterans' Affairs
by w.perriman 15 Oct, 2022
More posts
Share by: